A Cautionary Tale

I am writing this post as cautionary tale to fellow artists. I hope that is serves as a lesson to be learned through me and not one to be experienced in their own work.

Every now and again I’m reminded of my lesson when I’m riding down the road and I see a “for sale” sign. Or I’m watching TV and I see the commercial. I try to get over it but each time I see anything related to the mural I did for a very well known local Real Estate Agent, I feel like I’ve just been slapped in the face.

Here’s my story…

Back in 2009 I painted a mural of a map of Maryland with roadways and significant towns and cities for the office of this Real Estate Agent. They wanted something to show clients where their house would be in relation to their work. In designing the mural, I drew out the shape of the state, complete with each county, significant towns, and placed a Maryland flag in the background. I wanted to add something that was unique to the Real Estate Agent’s company and take up the “dead” space in the lower left area where West Virginia and Virgina usually are.  I decided to add a compass rose, being it a map and all, I thought it appropriate. I researched different designs and composed a compass rose that would compliment my design.  I placed the Real Estate Agent’s initials in the center of the compass rose. I presented my design to the Real Estate Agent’s wife and she like it. Just change out the blues (I had originally included blues because their website had the color.)

I installed it with the help of my amazing paper hanger.  I got paid for my work and that was that.

A few months later, I am at a meeting and I see the compass rose on some give-away pint glasses.  Hmm, I thought..not sure how to comprehend. I took a glass and put it in my bag.  Then I started seeing my compass rose, the one I designed for the mural, all over the place…on ads, on signs, on brochures, on commercials, on everything! Needless to say I was dumbfounded.  And angry!

I talked it over with my family and some fellow artists. I did research on copyright law.  I decided to write a letter. It was responded to by his lawyer.  “You can’t copyright a compass rose.” I then got my lawyer involved.  I didn’t want to go there but anyway.  The image was clearly taken from my mural and wasn’t in use before the mural’s execution.  The composition, colors (well, the initials were black instead of red) were IDENTICAL.  In educating myself about copyright law and art, I learned that ANYTIME an artist touches pencil (or brush) to paper, that work instantly is covered by copyright. Here is a good explanation. But, come to find out, because I had not registered my mural with the copyright office and had a clause in my contract that all of my work is owned by me, I stood little chance in court to come out with any money left in my pocket.  See, even though as an artist I owned the copyright to my work, I didn’t bring it up within 3 months of discovering the theft.  If I had, I would have been able to recoup all of my court costs if I were to have won. But because the amount of money it would take to take the Real Estate Agent to court far outweighed the piddly amount of money I had asked for in compensation, it wasn’t in my favor. I still could, it would just bankrupt me. I’d be out more money than what I was trying to get.

So…lesson learned. I have put things in place so that I am protected and have learned what my rights are.

Next time you see that compass rose, smile and say “Gee, what nice work, Dee!”

7 Replies to “A Cautionary Tale”

  1. I’m so sorry that happened to you Dee. That would really upset me also. Thank you so much for sharing and educating fellow artists! I appreciate you.
    ~Karen 🙂

  2. And some people have no shame. Too bad that you’d probably get sued got using the r e agent’s name but perhaps local folks already know of whom you speak by the description if your artwork. The cost of an education….

    1. Thanks Donna. Yes, I did not publish his name due to the fact that I would most likely get a letter in the mail. But everyone around these parts has seen said logo and can easily put two and two together. Hoping Karma will do its thing.

  3. That was a real lesson Dee! I had no idea that mural work could be copyrighted. Does that mean I have to take out a copyright every time I paint a mural? How do you do that anyway? One restaurant I did a mural for, used the mural for its menus and print ads, and I had no idea about copyright laws then.

    1. Hey Chris-
      I can email you more details, but the short of it is yes. Each time you do a mural you should register it, however, I only do if its in a commercial setting since that is more likely to be misused. And if you do, its not a “work for hire. That only applies to people working for a company. It was a bummer of a lesson. I wish that copyright were taught in art school. A thought would be to have a seminar at my studio for interested artists and we can all learn more about the do’s and dont’s.

  4. Hey Dee
    Yes , please email me the details. As for art school, the only thing it seems to teach is how to be a snob and not make a living doing so.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s